Chocolate & Vanilla Star Cookies

MADE BY RUSTIC BAKERY IN LARKSPUR, CALIFORNIA

MOUTH SAYS...

We’re seeing stars: Ever since Rustic Bakery’s chewy, five-pointed cookies hit our tasting table, we’ve been star-crossed trying to get our hands on another box.
 
Husband-and-wife baking team Carol and Josh make their signature old-fashioned sugar cookie dough with – you guessed it – sugar and butter! Half the dough is mixed with vanilla bean sourced from Madagascar; the other half is blended with toasty chocolate.
 
The final thin, soft, bite-size cookies have us thanking our lucky stars that Rustic Bakery keeps cranking out some of our favorite festive treats.
 
tip of the tongue

Scatter a few star-shaped sugar cookies ’round the edges of a holiday cookie plate. Shoot for the moon and pair with a tall, cold glass of milk.

  • $8.75 for 5 oz