Eat, Drink And Be indie: Tasty Recipes, Inspiring Maker Stories & Exclusives Served Daily

Plymouth Artisan Cheese

Plymouth cheesemaker Jesse Werner was born and raised in Vermont but went halfway around the world before starting his career in cheesemaking. He completed a degree in sociology in Massachusetts, a certificate in business English in Seville, Spain, and an MBA in Prague, Czech Republic. All those degrees just weren't enough. He was hungry for something more. Back in Vermont in 2008-09, Jesse attended the Vermont Institute of Artisanal Cheese to study cheesemaking – its chemistry, microbiology and design principles. 

Now, he heads up cheesemaking at one of the oldest cheese operations in the country, founded in 1890 by John Coolidge, father of President Calvin Coolidge. Plymouth produces artisanal raw cow’s milk cheese with milk from a single herd on a local farm -- talk about terroire! They are granular curd cheeses, a style brought to the New World by its first European settlers. They require a lot of time and manual labor (the curds and whey must be repeatedly stirred and drained), so they're incredibly rare. Not only is Plymouth preserving this distinctive American heritage style, they're also making some of the most delicious cheddars we have ever tasted. 

maker website:

Article index

  • AHeirloom

    You can imagine a nervous groom working on his vows up to the minute before he says, “I do,” but...

    Read more
  • Bench

    What’s old is new again. But you know that. Jason Enos and Chris Fitzgerald founded Brack Mountain Wine Company in Sonoma’s...

    Read more
  • Other Brother

    While Ben Herrmann and Evan Loewy share no DNA, they both have olive oil in their blood. The friends grew...

    Read more
  • Cooking for Isaiah

    You’d trust that a mom with a teenage son who was diagnosed gluten- and dairy-intolerant more than a decade ago...

    Read more
  • Next